More threads by David Baxter PhD

David Baxter PhD

Late Founder
The Highly Sensitive Person in Love
by Therese Borchard, Beyond Blue
Friday August 7, 2009

Elaine Aron, whose book The Highly Sensitive Person I've discussed often on Beyond Blue, also writes about the topic of sensitive-types in relationships. In fact, she devoted a whole book to it, The Highly Sensitive Person in Love. Here are some interesting facts on sensitive people and relationships and why she wrote a whole book about it ...

Most of us assume that the success of a relationship between friends or lovers depends on having good communication skills or sharing similar interests. But consider this: A 1995 study found that 50 percent of the risk of divorce is genetically determined. Does this mean success and fulfillment in social life are inherited? What can we do about that?

The single largest reason for this genetic effect is not a "divorce gene," I'm certain. (To say something is genetically determined doesn't clarify much--wearing skirts or owning a rifle is almost totally "genetically determined," thanks to the genes for gender plus a lot of cultural moderators.) Genetics enter into marriage because of the way that certain inherited temperaments cause trouble in relationships. They cause trouble only because most of us are totally ignorant about the reality of the drastic differences that can exist among nervous systems. But with the right guidance, the many "mismatches" in this world can have the most fulfilling relationships of all.

HSPs in Love
Let's start with the temperament we know, sensitivity. About 20% of us are highly sensitive persons (HSPs); at least 34% of love relationships involve an HSP. And everyone has at least one HSP friend. I have found that when HSPs aren't understood by themselves and others, that spells trouble. That's surely part of why my data show that, on the average HSPs, are a bit happier paired with each other. They understand each other.

My data also show that on the average HSPs' relationships in general are less happy--implying that relationships HSPs are in are less happy, at least for the HSP. Why? HSPs have nervous systems that pick up more on subtleties in the world and reflect on them deeply. That means, for starters, that they will tend to demand more depth in their relationships in order to be satisfied; see more threatening consequences in their partners' flaws or behaviors; reflect more and, if the signs indicate it, worry about how things are going.

Because HSPs are picking up on so much, they are also more prone to overstimulation, quicker to feel stress--including the stimulation and stress that can arise in any intense, intimate interactions. They need more down time, which can cause a partner to feel left out. They find different things enjoyable compared to others.
 

justhere

Member
I am definitely a HSP and in no relationship with only a scattered few friends who live elsewhere. My parents live closeby as does my sister and her family, though I dont see them often. I am seriously thinking that it would be less painful for me and hurt less if I moved and became a Recluse. Is this an answer for those of us like me who ruminate over past hurts whether it be from friends, coworkers, bosses, I am so easily hurt that I just want to stop feeling overwhelmed, rejected, and sad. Would living alone in some rural area help me? Must I give up the notion of finding a friend who gets me and accepts me, even values me? I feel this is a probable answer for me. I am middle aged and again, is it possible to suppress my desires and to live out my life alone and not seeking relationships?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Fiver

Member
Moving into isolation seems like it would be a convenient excuse avoid learning to accept that pain is a part of life. Of course, I'm being a hypocrite because I've been isolating all summer. But it's not a fun place to live, in isolation. You'll be sensitive to your surroundings no matter where you place yourself. I'd prefer to be in an area where I have even a remote chance of finding someone who understands the way I operate and think, someone who will be less inclined to hurt me. You won't find that unless you're out there where it can happen.

The question is, do you want to find someone? Or would you be happier being alone and always wondering...?
 

justhere

Member
i posted a response but to the wrong thread my apologies

---------- Post added at 03:15 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:09 PM ----------

Last night I read a post, I believed to be on this thread, that was quite harsh and now LOL I cannot locate it. Perhaps the writer deleted it, wisely, because it was unwarranted towards me reflecting her anger towards someone in her life personally. I am glad for that, since I am not here to debate anything.

For the love of God! I am having troubles it seems to post. Anyway, though I have objections to Fiver's post to me, I will move on!
 
Last edited:

Fiver

Member
justhere, I meant no disrespect and in fact was only asking questions that I've similarly (albeit not exactly the same) recently asked of myself. If you feel I was harsh or rude, please take my assurance that I certainly meant to be neither, and there was absolutely NO negativity directed toward you whatsoever in my response.

I apologize if I did not form my thoughts in a way that made them clear to anyone but myself. My posting history will show that it is often necessary to use a road map to figure out what I'm trying to say. Again, I humbly apologize if I offended you, for that was the least of my intentions.
 

David Baxter PhD

Late Founder
Last night I read a post, I believed to be on this thread, that was quite harsh and now LOL I cannot locate it. Perhaps the writer deleted it, wisely, because it was unwarranted towards me reflecting her anger towards someone in her life personally. I am glad for that, since I am not here to debate anything.

For the love of God! I am having troubles it seems to post. Anyway, though I have objections to Fiver's post to me, I will move on!

justhere, I meant no disrespect and in fact was only asking questions that I've similarly (albeit not exactly the same) recently asked of myself. If you feel I was harsh or rude, please take my assurance that I certainly meant to be neither, and there was absolutely NO negativity directed toward you whatsoever in my response.

I apologize if I did not form my thoughts in a way that made them clear to anyone but myself. My posting history will show that it is often necessary to use a road map to figure out what I'm trying to say. Again, I humbly apologize if I offended you, for that was the least of my intentions.

I don't see Fiver's reply as harsh or angry, justhere. I suspect you're reacting to the word "excuse" in this sentence:

Moving into isolation seems like it would be a convenient excuse avoid learning to accept that pain is a part of life.

But if you view the post as a whole, what Fiver is saying makes a lot of sense:

it's not a fun place to live, in isolation. You'll be sensitive to your surroundings no matter where you place yourself. I'd prefer to be in an area where I have even a remote chance of finding someone who understands the way I operate and think, someone who will be less inclined to hurt me. You won't find that unless you're out there where it can happen.

The question is, do you want to find someone? Or would you be happier being alone and always wondering...?

That's a question I do think you need to ask yourself... would you really be happier? or would you just be "safe" but lonely?
 

justhere

Member
Thank you David Baxter for your generous and thoughtfully stated reply. I dont see some things in my life as a *choice* and that is, I now see, what I reacted to. Not having friends is hardly how I'd like to live:(
 
Replying is not possible. This forum is only available as an archive.
Top