More threads by David Baxter PhD

David Baxter PhD

Late Founder
Unwanted Thoughts? Snap the Rubber Band!

by Harriet Lerner, Ph.D., Psychology Today
October 20, 2010

A number of practices and techniques are available to help you loosen the grip of any type of anxiety-driven, unproductive thought pattern. Since I'm not a technique-oriented therapist, I often learn from my therapy clients what works, rather than the other way around.

One woman, Katy, tells me about a technique for managing her unwanted judgmental thoughts about herself and others. She learned it from a woman's magazine she came upon at her hairdresser's.

The article suggested a "rubber band technique" for stopping thoughts. Katy has elaborated on the technique, using her imagination and self-knowledge to create a tool that works for her.

Here's what she does: When Katy finds herself drifting into negative thinking, she snaps a rubber band on her wrist and says to herself in a spirit of playfulness, "Hello again, you silly little critical thought! How are you today?" If she's alone, she may say this out loud. Then Katy puts the thought in an imaginary red dumpster and lets it ride down a railroad track where it gets dumped into a pile at the end of the track.

She doesn't try to stop the thoughts (which is impossible), but she's found a way to say howdy to them, and to use her wonderful sense of humor to give each judgmental thought--these days focused on her "loser brother"-- a little welcome and sendoff.

Katy doesn't think too much about why her brain wraps around "negative thinking" at one point in time and not another. Her belief is that the variations in her thought patterns have more to do with the vicissitudes of her "weird brain chemistry" as she calls it, than anything psychological that she needs to attend to.

No matter. Katy has a gift for silliness, and practicing this technique, combined with daily aerobic exercise, has so far offered her the best relief in loosening the grip of unwanted thoughts.
 

Daniel E.

daniel@psychlinks.ca
Administrator
She learned it from a woman's magazine she came upon at her hairdresser's.

Figures. Anyway, it's often not recommended:

Thought stopping, either through shouting "STOP" or snapping a rubber band in response to the spike is clearly not recommended and may actually be detrimental. As discussed previously, this technique would in effect sensitize the brain to the unwanted thought by alerting the "R" that potential punishment is associated with the spike. Theoretically, the spikes would thus increase due to this heightened sensitivity. Future research may bare this out...

Ultimately, as with all forms of OCD, living with uncertainty and risk taking are the antidotes to this disorder.

http://forum.psychlinks.ca/obsessive-compulsive-disorder-ocd/16992-ocd-thinking-the-unthinkable.html
 

David Baxter PhD

Late Founder
I think in this context it's being suggested as a distraction technique and a technique to de-power the thought or urge:

When Katy finds herself drifting into negative thinking, she snaps a rubber band on her wrist and says to herself in a spirit of playfulness, "Hello again, you silly little critical thought! How are you today?" If she's alone, she may say this out loud. Then Katy puts the thought in an imaginary red dumpster and lets it ride down a railroad track where it gets dumped into a pile at the end of the track.

She doesn't try to stop the thoughts (which is impossible), but she's found a way to say howdy to them, and to use her wonderful sense of humor to give each judgmental thought--these days focused on her "loser brother"-- a little welcome and sendoff.
 

defect

Member
I think that realizing the possibility to consciously intervene a negative thought and disrupt it's course is extremely empowering.
I interpreted this article as an example of just that.
 

Daniel E.

daniel@psychlinks.ca
Administrator
Most thoughts are intrusive/unbidden. I think the efficacy of this technique is not from the use of the rubber band but from simply labeling/identifying the thought as unimportant ("silly") and then carrying on with one's daily tasks.

And for every book you find that recommends the rubber-band technique, you can find one that says it doesn't work or can actually make things worse (thought rebounding).

I consider this use of the rubber band as not unlike EMDR where the use of the prop is unnecessary but harmless.
 

Daniel E.

daniel@psychlinks.ca
Administrator
"As Dr. Leahy points out, behavioral thought stoppage techniques, once part of the treatment of choice for anxiety / worry are not as effective as once believed. Cognitive behavioral approaches that teach acceptance and mindfulness, and learning to tolerate unwanted thoughts and not act on them are more effective strategies to reduce suffering."

~ Adam Russo, PhD
 
Replying is not possible. This forum is only available as an archive.
Top