More threads by David Baxter PhD

David Baxter PhD

Late Founder
Maybe It's Not All Good or All Bad
by Ginelle Testa, Tiny Buddha
August 27, 2018

"You are the sky. Everything else - it’s just the weather." ~ Pema Chödrön

A farmer has a horse for many years; it helps him earn his livelihood and raise his son. One day, the horse runs away. His neighbor says sympathetically, “Such bad luck.”

The farmer replies, “Maybe. Who knows?”

The next day, the horse makes its way back home bringing with it another horse. The neighbor says with a smile, “Such good luck.”

The farmer replies, “Maybe. Who knows?”

The following day, the farmer’s son rides the new horse and seeks to tame it. In the process, he breaks his leg. The neighbor says sympathetically, “Such bad luck.”

The farmer replies, “Maybe. Who knows?”

The last day of the story, the military comes to the village to draft all able-bodied young men to fight in a war. The son is exempt from the draft due to his broken leg. You can guess what the neighbor said, and how the farmer replied.

This Zen Buddhist parable illustrates that we never really know exactly why things are unfolding the way that they are, and that labeling them as “good” or “bad” is useless. It only gets us all wrapped up in the ups and downs. Riding the car of this dichotomy only takes us on a roller coaster ride while our emotions are following whatever storyline is in front of us.

Because I’m a human, I do this all of the time. I think that something fits neatly into either category and I place it there then try to not look back. Usually that ends with those contents spilling out all over the place. Like when I try to make certain foods “good” or “bad.” Food has no morality, and categorizing it in this way just brings me shame.

David Allen explained that the Taoists have their own way of interpreting the complication: the yin and yang symbol. “Good” flows into “bad” and the two are even contained in one another. They can’t really be separated.


Let’s explore this concept of “good,” “bad,” and “maybe” more with a story from my life.

The story starts with the “good.” Not too far out of college I had a cushy tech job that I absolutely adored. I relished in the fact that I was doing what I loved and that I had been promoted to that position after working really hard.

The perks were great. We had flexible hours, leaving room for naps on my work from home days. My favorite perk was a giant snack room, full of all kinds of goodies. We were swimming in the startup benefits, and by all measures, I was happy. However, I didn’t realize how much the perks had swept me up into working all of the time until I collapsed.

I had a breakdown. I could be found writhing in emotional pain, my brain wanting me dead. How quickly this good turned to “bad.” I was taken by ambulance to a locked ward. This took me totally off guard.

Everyday things like my laptop cord and makeup mirrors were taken from me lest I harm myself. I slept in a hallway of sixteen girls, and a nurse opened our doors every fifteen minutes at night to check to see if we were still breathing. The food was sub par at best.

I wanted to die. I had a total mental health collapse and realized I had been running myself ragged at this job. I had to quit it because I knew that this stay wasn’t going to be a quick fix. I had five more hospitalizations that year, and I thought that my life was over.

While reflecting on what had brought me to this point, I realized that the job wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows; this job that I adored also happened to be wildly demanding of my time, even beyond the forty-hour workweek.

The office had terrible boundaries, with lots of people dating one another (including myself at one point). Most harmful, though, was the unlimited stash of anytime booze (I’m a recovering alcoholic).

Later, reflecting on the time I spent hospitalized, I realized my experiences weren’t all “bad.” My time in and out of psych wards has reminded me how strong I am — the strength it took to get help instead of killing myself was something I didn’t know I had.

I thought I’d stay on the path to destruction for much longer, but my will to live came through. I was shown, despite my skepticism, that I’m indeed never alone; my loved ones showered me with support.

It took eighteen months of rest before I was ready to go back to work. I struggled with feeling inadequate and useless during this time. I was so accustomed to working like a maniac that rest felt foreign to me. Bringing us to the present, I’m finally well enough to be able to work. Though I’ve gotten a job that pays much less than my last one and it isn’t even close to as prestigious. I’m calling it my “get-well job.”

I’m still working through some shame around it, wanting to call this “bad,” even though I know it’s a mix of things.

Instead of calling it “bad,” I do my best to return to “maybe” with a shrug.

I’m not saying that I’m able to be perfectly non-judgmental and unattached, living without worry at my job and feeling perfectly confident when talking about it. Though some days I can just let things be what they are. I can notice that voice inside that’s yelling at me and I can soothe it. I can create a new script and I can practice radical acceptance by not fighting against what’s going on in my mind.

Looking back, I called my job “good” and the psych wards “bad,” though there were no clear categories. Good is great, but it doesn’t last forever. Bad can hurt, but it doesn’t last forever either. There was a bit of a mix of everything. Much of life is this way.

I don’t know why things happen the way that they do, and I never know what’s going to happen next. Perhaps this job will benefit my life in ways I could never predict. Maybe it’ll keep me where I’m at, or make things worse, I just don’t know.

The thing is, though, once I start to move past outcomes I can be more present to and flexible with what’s happening.

I can just enjoy learning to use the espresso machine at my new job rather than worrying about what people think of my new job choice. I can practice gentleness around my mental health, remaining non-judgmental when I have a difficult day. I can do this instead of thrashing against what is, letting my mind carry me to dreams of what things could be and being angry about how things are.

I can work with whatever emotions come up, knowing that it’s all the path. I can’t prevent life from happening and I can’t always force what I want to take place. What I do have control of is l how I react to everything and today I’m trying to have a “maybe” attitude.

Lastly, I was reminded by being knocked down by my job and mental health that the human spirit is wildly resilient. I got back up; I did it very slowly, but I did it.


About Ginelle Testa
Ginelle Testa is a passionate wordsmith. She's a queer gal whose passions include recovery/sobriety, social justice, body positivity, and intersectional feminism. In the rare moments she isn't writing, you can find her holding her own in a recreational street hockey league, thrifting eclectic attire, and imperfectly practicing Buddhism. You can find her at


Bah humbug

just kidding good article
Replying is not possible. This forum is only available as an archive.